ScanMyEstimate
Independent Book-Time Verification

Audited Auto Repair Estimates

Compare actual mechanic repair quotes against published industry flat-rate guides, OEM factory warranty schedules, and regional door rates. See how estimating software markups and labor overlap inflation are detected and negotiated down.

• Real-World Audit Case Studies
Independent Auto Repair Estimate Audits and Price Benchmarking
2019 Honda Civic EX 1.5L Turbo
San Jose, CA (95123)
0W-20 Synthetic Oil Change (3.7 qt) + Brake Fluid Hydraulic Flush (DOT 4)
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $388.50
Fair Standard $292.00
Potential Savings $96.50
Vehicle Segment Japanese Compact

Detected +0.6 hr overage on brake fluid flush labor ($216.00 quoted vs $108.00 standard flat rate).

2018 Honda CR-V EX-L 1.5L Turbo
Sunnyvale, CA (94086)
Front Ceramic Brake Pads + Coated Brake Rotors Pair + Caliper Service
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $626.00
Fair Standard $418.00
Potential Savings $208.00
Vehicle Segment Compact SUV

Detected inflated 2.0 hr labor time vs 1.4 hr standard flat-rate guide, plus 65% markup on replacement rotors.

2016 Mercedes-Benz E350 3.5L V6
Sunnyvale, CA (94086)
Front Ceramic Brake Pads, Coated Rotors & Wear Sensors Replacement
Fair Standard
Quoted Total $769.97
Fair Standard $688.00
Potential Savings $81.97
Vehicle Segment European Luxury

Estimating software +20% default labor markup detected, fully offset by shop courtesy discount credit.

2021 BMW X5 xDrive40i 3.0L Turbo
Newport Beach, CA (92660)
M-Sport 4-Piston Brake Pads, 374mm Semi-Floating Rotors & CBS Reset
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $1180.00
Fair Standard $840.00
Potential Savings $340.00
Vehicle Segment Luxury SUV

Dealership labor rate of $245/hr and 2.2 hrs billed vs 1.5 hrs standard factory flat rate.

2019 Toyota RAV4 XLE 2.5L Dynamic Force
Dallas, TX (75204)
OEM Iridium Spark Plugs (4x) + Micro-V Serpentine Drive Belt R&R
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $555.00
Fair Standard $390.00
Potential Savings $165.00
Vehicle Segment Compact SUV

Shop quoted 1.5 hrs for spark plugs (standard book time is 0.8 hr) and missed drive belt access overlap.

2018 Ford F-150 3.5L Twin-Turbo EcoBoost
Phoenix, AZ (85001)
Engine Water Pump Assembly R&R + Thermostat + Vacuum Coolant Bleed
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $1050.00
Fair Standard $785.00
Potential Savings $265.00
Vehicle Segment Full-Size Truck

Uncredited cooling system teardown overlap on thermostat replacement during water pump disassembly.

2017 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 5.3L V8
Denver, CO (80202)
High-Torque Starter Motor R&R + 12V Group 48 AGM Battery & BMS Relearn
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $890.00
Fair Standard $665.00
Potential Savings $225.00
Vehicle Segment Full-Size Truck

Starter motor labor billed at 2.2 hrs vs standard flat rate of 1.5 hrs on EcoTec3 chassis.

2020 Toyota Camry 2.5L 4-Cylinder
Atlanta, GA (30303)
High-Output 130A Alternator R&R + Drive Belt Tensioner Inspection
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $740.00
Fair Standard $560.00
Potential Savings $180.00
Vehicle Segment Midsize Sedan

Excessive labor time allocation and uncredited belt removal overlap on alternator service.

2018 Subaru Outback 2.5i Boxer AWD
Seattle, WA (98101)
Front Complete Strut Assemblies (Pair) + 4-Wheel Computer Alignment
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $1150.00
Fair Standard $880.00
Potential Savings $270.00
Vehicle Segment AWD Crossover

Quick-strut assemblies billed at bare-strut rebuild labor hours (2.8 hrs vs 1.8 hrs assembly time).

2019 Audi A4 2.0 TFSI Quattro
Chicago, IL (60601)
Timing Chain Kit, Hydraulic Tensioner & Lower Timing Cover Gasket
Overcharge Alert
Quoted Total $2450.00
Fair Standard $1890.00
Potential Savings $560.00
Vehicle Segment European Luxury

Factory warranty book time is 5.2 hrs; independent shop billed 6.8 hrs plus 40% markup on genuine Audi chain guides.